Tuesday, September 24, 2024

The Cleveland Browns Stadium (Now Huntington Bank Field)

 

Photo Credit

Photo Credit

Former Names: First Energy Stadium 2013 – 2023
Address: 100 Alfred Lerner Way
Location: Cleveland, Ohio
Owner: City of Cleveland
Operator: Cleveland Browns
Executive Suites: 143
Capacity: 67,431
Record Attendance: 73,718 (November 3rd, 2002
                                vs. Steelers)
Surface: Kentucky Bluegrass(1)
Broke Ground: May 15th, 1997
Opened: September 12th, 1999
Construction Cost: $283 million ($518 million in 2023
                              dollars(2))(3)
Architects: 
1.     HOK Sport(4)
2.     Robert P. Madison International, Inc.(5)
3.     Ralph Tyler Companies(6)
Project Manager: The Project Group(7)
Structural Engineer: Osborn Engineering(8)­­
Services Engineer: URS Corporation(9)
Tenants: Cleveland Browns (NFL) 1999 – Present

Cleveland Browns Stadium is a stadium in Cleveland, Ohio, primarily for football. It is the home field of the Cleveland Browns of the National Football League (NFL), and serves as a venue for other events such as college and high school football, soccer, hockey, and concerts. It opened in 1999 and was known as First Energy Stadium from 2013 to 2023.

The initial seating capacity was listed at 73,200 people, but following the first phase of a two-year renovation project in 2014, was reduced to the current capacity of 67,431. The stadium sits on 31 acres of land between Lake Erie and the Cleveland Memorial Shoreway in the North Coast Harbor area of downtown Cleveland, adjacent to the Great Lakes Science Center and the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Cleveland Stadium stood on the site from 1931 to 1996.(10)(11)­

History

Cleveland Browns Stadium is located on the site of Cleveland Stadium, commonly called Cleveland Municipal Stadium, a multipurpose facility built in 1931 that served as the Browns’ home field from their inception in 1946 through the 1995 season. During the 1995 season, owner Art Modell announced his plans to move the team to Baltimore, which resulted in legal action from the city of Cleveland and Browns season ticket holders. The day after the announcement was made, voters in Cuyahoga County approved an extension of the original 1990 sin tax on alcohol and tobacco products to fund renovations to Cleveland Stadium(12). Eventually, as part of the agreement between Modell, the city of Cleveland, and the NFL, the city agreed to tear down Cleveland Stadium and build a new stadium on the same site using the sin tax funds. Modell agreed to leave the Browns name, colors, and history in Cleveland and create a new identity for his franchise, eventually becoming the Baltimore Ravens, while the NFL agreed to reactivate the Browns by 1999 through expansion or relocation of another team. Demolition of the old stadium began in November 1996 and was completed in early 1997. Debris from the former stadium was submerged in Lake Erie and now serves as an artificial reef.

Ground was broken for the new stadium on May 15th, 1997, and it opened in July 1999. The first event was a preseason game between the Browns and the Minnesota Vikings on August 21st, followed the next week by a preseason game against the Chicago Bears. The first regular-season Browns game at the stadium was played the evening of September 12th, 1999, a 43 – 0 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers.(13)

Since 2011, the stadium has been referred to by some as the “Factory of Sadness”,(14) a name that was first coined that year by comedian and Browns fan Mike Polk. Polk made a video outside the stadium in which he complains about the team’s futility(14)­­. In 2021, after the Browns defeated the Steelers at Heinz Field, local TV station WKYC broadcast a segment with Polk where he “closed” the Factory of Sadness.(15)

Through the 2023 season, Cleveland Browns Stadium is the only NFL venue that has yet to host a postseason game in their current stadium, along with the Atlanta Falcons, Las Vegas Raiders, Los Angeles Chargers and New York Jets. Those facilities, however, have each hosted the Super Bowl, while the Jets’ home, MetLife Stadium, and the Chargers’ home, SoFi Stadium, have also hosted home playoff games for their other tenants, the New York Giants and Los Angeles Rams, respectively.

Facility

The stadium was designed by Populous, which was known at the time as the Sport Venue Event Division of Hellmuth, Obata & Kassabaum (HOK). Indianapolis-based Huber, Hunt & Nichols was the construction manager. The stadium is a concrete and glass structure, using precast concrete and cast-in-place for the upper concourse. Natural stone accents were used at the base of the stadium. The construction of the concrete superstructure took more than 6,000 truckloads of concrete, or the equivalent of 60,000 cubic yards, with a weight of approximately 235 million pounds.

The playing surface is Kentucky Bluegrass irrigated field, with a sand-soil root zone and an underground heating system that involves nine boilers and 40 miles of underground piping. The heating system prevents the field from freezing and extends the growing season of the turf(1). Although it was designed for football, the playing surface was built large enough to accommodate international soccer matches.

The eastern seating section is the home of the Dawg Pound, a section bleacher seats. It was designed as a successor to the original Dawg Pound at Cleveland Stadium, the bleacher section also located in the east end zone. When Cleveland Browns Stadium opened in 1999, the Dawg Pound was a 10,644, double-deck area. During stadium renovations in 2014, the upper level of the Dawg Pound was reduced to make way for a new, larger scoreboard, auxiliary scoreboard, and additional fan areas, and the bleacher seating in the upper level was replaced with chairbacks.(16)

Renovations

In 2013, Browns owner Jimmy Haslam announced a modernization project for Cleveland Browns Stadium. The project included two phases that took place during the NFL off-seasons in 2014 and 2015. Phase one included improving the audio system, installing new scoreboards three times the size of the original scoreboards and at the time, the fourth largest in an NFL stadium, as well as adding more seats to the lower bowl(17). Phase two included concession improvements, upgrades to technology connectivity, graphics throughout the stadium, and enhancing the premium suites. The renovations reduced the stadium’s capacity to approximately 68,000(18). The total cost of the renovations was estimated at $120 million with the city of Cleveland paying $30 million over 15 years and the Browns covering the rest of the cost.(19)

Stadium Naming

The city specifically chose not to sell the naming rights to the stadium itself, which is highly unusual for major American stadiums built in recent years. However, it instead sold the naming rights to each of the facility’s four main entrance gates. Originally, the gates were named for National City Bank, Steris Corp., CoreComm Inc., and the Cleveland Clinic Sports Health(20). The arrangement was later discontinued, though has been partially restored. As of the 2022 season, the southwest gate is sponsored by Meijer, the southeast gate is sponsored by University Hospitals of Cleveland, and the northeast gate by Electronic Merchant Systems.(21)

Randy Lerner sold the Browns to Jimmy Haslam, CEO of truck stop chain Pilot Flying J, in August 2012. Before the deal officially closed in October 2012, Haslam announced he would sell the stadium’s naming rights. Haslam effectively ruled out his family business as buying the naming rights, mentioning that he had received offers for the naming rights, and that none of them are based in his home state of Tennessee(22)(23). On January 14th, 2013, it was reported that the naming rights were sold to FirstEnergy Corporation, the Akron-based electric utility serving most of northeastern Ohio(24). The Browns announced the following day that the stadium would be renamed “FirstEnergy Stadium, Home of the Cleveland Browns”, with the deal getting Cleveland City Council approval on February 15th, 2013(25). Ironically, the stadium’s power is actually generated and paid for through the city’s power utility, Cleveland Public Power, instead of FirstEnergy.(26)

Because of the Ohio nuclear bribery scandal and FirstEnergy’s involvement in it, Cleveland City Council passed a resolution in June 2022 to urge FirstEnergy to relinquish its naming rights(27). At the time, the Browns nor FirstEnergy motioned that the agreement would be revoked(28). The Browns then announced on April 13th, 2023, that the team and FirstEnergy had come to an agreement to immediately terminate the naming rights deal, restoring the stadium’s original moniker(29). The original agreement was set to expire in 2029.(26)

Services

The stadium does not have public parking facilities. However, there are several adjacent parking facilities: the Port Authority visitors lot, the West 3rd Street parking lot, the Great Lakes Science Center parking garage, and the city of Cleveland municipal parking lots, the latter being where tailgating on game days is common. Additionally, the West 3rd Street station of Cleveland’s Waterfront light rail line serves the stadium.(30)

Other Events

In addition to home games for the Browns, the stadium hosts other events during the year, including college football, high school football, international soccer, concerts, and other events.

The Ohio Classic, a college football game featuring Historically Black Colleges and Universities, was held at the stadium in 2003 and 2005. In September 2006, it hosted the game between the Bowling Green Falcons and Wisconsin Badgers, which had an announced attendance of 30,307 people(31). From 2007 to 2009, the stadium hosted an event known as the Patriot Bowl, a season-opening game intended to showcase teams from the Mid-American Conference (MAC). The first Patriot Bowl featured the Army Black Knights and Akron Zips and drew 17,835 fans(32). The following season, Boston College defeated Kent State in the second Patriot Bowl on August 30th, 2008 in front of 10,788 people(33). The third and final Patriot Bowl game was between the Ohio State Buckeyes and Toledo Rockets. While the game was considered a home game for Toledo, the crowd of 71,727 was mostly Ohio State fans.(34)(35)

Cleveland Browns Stadium has hosted numerous high school football games, including playoff games of the Ohio High School Athletic Association (OHSAA) tournament(36). In 2010 and 2011, the Browns revived the Charity Football Game, which had been held from 1931 to 1987 and was hosted at Cleveland Stadium until 1970(37). The revived version, called the High School Football Charity Games, was a doubleheader that featured four area high school teams. The 2010 edition, played August 28th, featured Saint Edward High School and Mentor High School in the first game, and Saint Ignatius and Lake Catholic High School in the second game(38). The 2011 edition, played August 27th, featured Mayfield High School and Medina High School in the first game, and Glenville High School and St. Edward’s High School in the second game(39). The rivalry game between two of the Cleveland area’s largest parochial high schools, St. Ignatius and St. Edward, has been held at the stadium on three occasions: October 2016, which had 17,400 fans in attendance; October 2018; and again, in September 2020(40)(41)(42). St. Ignatius returned to the stadium in August 2022 against Mentor.(43)

In addition to football and other field sports, Monster Jam has been held at the stadium on two occasions, the first being July 2nd, 2022, and then again on June 3rd, 2023(44)(45). The stadium was also the setting for Progressive Corporation’s At Home campaign showing Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield living with his wife in the facility(46). Cleveland Browns stadium hosted the 37th edition of WWE’s premium live event SummerSlam, with an attendance of 57,791 on August 3rd, 2024.(47)(48)

Soccer

Cleveland Browns Stadium is a periodic host for both the United States men’s (USMNT) and women’s national soccer (USWNT) teams. The stadium hosted a match between the USMNT and Venezuela in the run-up to the 2006 FIFA World Cup, a 2 – 0 victory for the US, and a 4 – 2 loss in 2013 against Belgium that drew 27,720 fans(49). The stadium, then known as FirstEnergy Stadium, hosted games in the group stage of the 2017 CONCACAF Gold Cup, with the USMNT playing July 15th, 2017, against Nicaragua as part of a doubleheader that also included Panama and Martinique. Both Panama and the United States won their respective matches by a score of 3 – 0(50)(51)(52). The stadium again hosted group stage play during the 2019 CONCACAF Gold Cup, with Panama defeating Guyana 4 – 2 and the USMNT winning 6 – 0 over Trinidad and Tobago.(53)(54)

The USWNT has played at the stadium on three occasions, with the most recent being in 2018. It hosted a 4 – 0 friendly victory against Germany in 2010 and the second leg of a friendly series with Japan in 2016, a 2 – 0 win for the USWNT. The game against Japan had 23,535 fans in attendance, the largest crowd to see the USWNT play in Ohio(55). The USWNT returned on June 12th, 2018m in a game against China, won by the U.S. 2 – 1.(56)(57)

Concerts

A limited number of concerts have been held at Cleveland Browns Stadium since it opened. The first concert held in the stadium was George Strait in 2000, followed in 2001 by NSYNC, as part of their PopOdyssey Tour, and The Three Tenors. Kenny Chesney has performed at the stadium on three occasions. His Flip-Flop Summer Tour came to Cleveland in 2007, followed by The Poets and Pirates Tour in 2008, and the Brothers of the Sun Tour in 2012. In 2015, the stadium was part of the circuits for One Direction and their On the Road Again Tour as well as Luke Bryan and his Kick the Dust Up Tour(58). U2 performed at Cleveland Browns Stadium July 1st, 2017 as part of The Joshua Tree Tour 2017. Tickets for the concert went on sale January 17th, and were sold out the following day(59). Concerts held at the stadium in 2018 included Taylor Swift as part of her Reputation Stadium Tour on July 17th, followed by Beyonce and Jay-Z on July 25th as part of their On the Run II Tour.(60)(61)

Concerts scheduled for 2020 and 2021 were cancelled as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic, but returned to the stadium in 2022. Def Leppard and Motley Crue continued their The Stadium Tour on July 14th in front of 34,815 people, and the Machine Gun Kelly, a Cleveland-area native, held the last US stop of his Mainstream Sellout Tour on August 13th, playing in front of 42,086 fans in a concert that featured Avril Lavigne, Travis Barker, Willow Smith, Trippie Redd, and 44phantom(62)(63). The Rolling Stones, originally scheduled to perform during the No Filter Tour, performed to a sold-out crowd on June 15th, 2024, as part of their Hackney Diamonds Tour(64). Billy Joel and Rod Stewart are scheduled to perform at the stadium on September 13th, 2024.(65)

Hockey

Cleveland Browns Stadium has also served as an outdoor venue for ice hockey, the first time being in early 2023. The headline event was announced August 22nd, 2022, a college ice hockey game between Michigan and Ohio State, titled Faceoff on the Lake(66). Later, on October 11th, 2022, it was announced that the stadium would also host an American Hockey League (AHL) game between the Cleveland Monsters and the Wilkes-Barre/Scranton Penguins, titled the Cleveland Monsters Outdoor Classic(67). The games highlighted multiple events the stadium hosted using the temporary ice rink built on the playing field.

The first ice hockey game played at the stadium on February 17th, 2023, between John Carroll University and Canisius College of the American Collegiate Hockey Association (ACHA), a club-level college ice hockey league(68). The game, titled the “John Carroll University Outdoor Classic”, was won by John Carroll, 5 – 4(69). Faceoff on the Lake was held the following day, where Ohio State defeated Michigan 4 – 2 in front of 45,523 fans, which set an attendance record for an outdoor college hockey game at a neutral site(70). The Cleveland Monsters Outdoor Classic was held March 4th, but the start had to be delayed five hours due to ice conditions. The Monsters went on to defeat the Penguins 3 – 2 in overtime with an attendance of 22,875.(71)

Additional ice hockey games were held at the stadium in between Faceoff on the Lake and the Monsters Outdoor Classic. A United States Hockey League (USHL) game, known as the USHL Cleveland Classic, was held February 22nd between the Youngstown Phantoms and Cedar Rapids Roughriders. The game was won by the Phantoms 4 – 1(72). The Ohio High School Athletic Association (OHSAA) hosted two playoff games at the stadium on February 25th and 26th. They were also scheduled to host games on March 3rd, but the March 3rd games had to be moved to an indoor facility in nearby Brooklyn, Ohio, due to rain(73). Public skating was also available on February 22nd and 25th.(74)

References:

1.     Newcomb, Tim (September 29, 2015). "Turf time:
        November 2, 2016.

2.     1634–1699: McCusker, J. J. (1997). How Much
        1700–1799: McCusker, J. J. (1992). How Much
        American Antiquarian Society. 1800–present:
        Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis.
        Retrieved February 29, 2024.

3.     "Cleveland Browns Stadium". Ballparks.com.
        Retrieved October 30, 2012.

4.     "Stadia Architectural Design". Populous.
        2016. Retrieved November 2, 2016.

5.     "History". Robert P. Madison International,
        Inc. 2016. Archived from the original on
        December 13, 2018. Retrieved November 2, 
        2016.

6.     "Ralph Tyler". The History Makers. 2016.
        Retrieved November 2, 2016.

7.     Cleveland Browns Stadium (PDF). Weston,
        Inc. 1999. Archived from the original (PDF)
        on February 20, 2011. Retrieved 
        November 2, 2016.

8.     "Osborn Engineering Co.". The Encyclope-
        dia of Cleveland History. Case Western
        November 2, 2016.

9.     "A strong local presence". BXMagazine.
        com. Archived from the original on
        March 13, 2008.

10.   2016 Official NFL Record and Fact
        2014. p. 58. Archived from the original
        (PDF) on November 6, 2015.
        Retrieved February 8, 2016.

11.   "About Us". FirstEnergy Stadium.
        2017. Archived from the original on July 
        10, 2017. Retrieved July 6, 2017.

12.   "PRO FOOTBALL DAILY REPORT :
        November 8, 1995. Retrieved September
        19, 2016.

13.   "Cleveland Browns - 1999". Cleveland
        Browns. 2015. Retrieved
        December 9, 2015.

14.   Jump up to:a b "Are Cleveland Browns
        The Plain Dealer. November 11, 2011.
        Archived from the original on August 3,
        2020. Retrieved December 1, 2015.

15.   "Mike Polk Jr. officially closes 'The
        January 8, 2021. Retrieved September
        2, 2021.

16.   Moore, Glenn (June 16, 2014).
        November 2, 2016.

17.    "Alec Scheiner Outlines FirstEnergy
         Journal. Retrieved June 18, 2014.

18.   "Cleveland Browns reveal 2-year
        proposal". Cleveland.com. November
        13, 2013. Retrieved November 2, 2016.

19.   Atassi, Leila (November 25, 2016).
        Stadium". Cleveland.com. Retrieved
        November 2, 2016.

20.   Mitchell, Eric (July 5, 1999). "Browns
        Business Journal. Retrieved October
        21, 2012.

21.   "Find your seat". ClevelandBrowns.com.
        Cleveland Browns. 2023. Retrieved
        April 4, 2023.

22.   "Pilot won't buy naming rights for First
        Energy Stadium". Newsnet5.com.
        Archived from the original on August
        14, 2012. Retrieved October 19, 2012.

23.   "UPDATE: Pilot Flying J's Haslam
        Retrieved October 19, 2012.

24.   "Browns to sell stadium naming rights".
        ESPN.com. Associated Press. January
        14, 2013. Retrieved January 15, 2013.

25.   Naymik, Mark (March 8, 2013).
        alike". The Plain Dealer. Cleveland
        Live LLC. Retrieved May 6, 2013.
        Sweeney let the naming-rights deal
        pass on February 15...

26.   Jump up to:a b Feran, Tom (January
        22, 2013). "Mike Polensek says utility
        company". Politifact Ohio. Retrieved
        November 2, 2016.

27.   Shaw, Courtney (June 6, 2022). "City
        stadium". News5Cleveland.com.
        Retrieved February 15, 2023.

28.   Schudel, Jeff (June 7, 2022). "Browns
        Retrieved February 15, 2023.

29.   "FirstEnergy and Cleveland Browns
        Browns.com. April 13, 2023.
        Retrieved April 13, 2023.

30.   "Directions & Parking". Cleveland
        BrownsStadium.com. Cleveland
        Browns. Retrieved June 25, 2024.

31.   "Wisconsin waltzes past Bowling
        ESPN.com. Associated Press.
        September 2, 2006. Retrieved
        November 1, 2016.

32.   "Zips 22, Black Knights 14". ESPN.com.
        Associated Press. September 2, 2007.
        Archived from the original on November
        3, 2016. Retrieved November 1, 2016.

33.   Blaudschun, Mark (August 31, 2008).
        September 2, 2008.

34.   Lesmerises, Doug (March 4, 2009).
        November 1, 2016.

35.   "Pryor, Ohio State feast on Toledo's
        porous defense". ESPN.com. September
        19, 2009. Archived from the original on
        November 4, 2016. Retrieved March 4, 2016.

36.   Tilton, Bill (June 10, 2010). "High school
        Retrieved July 11, 2010.

37.   "Charity Game". Encyclopedia of Cleveland
        History. Case Western Reserve University.
        May 11, 2018. Retrieved December 8, 2023.

38.   Holzheimer, Mike (June 23, 2010). "High
        Browns Stadium". Sun Post Herald.
        Retrieved December 8, 2023 – via
        Cleveland.com.

39.   Tilton, Bill (May 6, 2011). "High school
        Retrieved December 8, 2023.

40.   "St. Ignatius, St. Edward play at First
        2016. Retrieved November 1, 2016.

41.   "FirstEnergy Stadium was the site for
        Browns. October 27, 2018. Retrieved
        December 8, 2023.

42.   Goul, Matt (September 19, 2020). "No.
        Plain Dealer. Retrieved December 8, 2023
        – via Cleveland.com.

43.   Carey, Tyler (August 27, 2023). "Saint
        WKYC.com. WKYC. Retrieved
        December 8, 2023.

44.   Jewett, Larry. "Cleveland, OH - First
        Energy Stadium - July 2, 2023". Monster
        Jam.com. Monster Jam. Retrieved
        December 8, 2023.

45.   Jewett, Larry. "Cleveland, OH -
        2023". MonsterJam.com. Monster Jam.
        Retrieved December 8, 2023.

46.   "Progressive launches Season 2 of 'At
        WKYC. September 2, 2020. Retrieved
        January 31, 2021.
 
47.   Lambert, Jeremy (March 12, 2024).
        Retrieved March 12, 2024.

48.   Wolf, Zachary (July 23, 2024). "Latest
        Gambling Sites. Retrieved August 2,
        2024.

49.   Lyndall, Craig (May 2013). "Cleveland
        WaitingForNextYear. Retrieved
        November 1, 2016.

50.   Stejskal, Stan (December 19, 2016).
        schedule". MLSSoccer.com.
        Retrieved December 20, 2016.

51.   "2017 CONCACAF Gold Cup:
        July 7, 2017. Retrieved July 10, 2017.

52.   "U.S. defeats Nicaragua, captures
        July 16, 2017. Retrieved July 17,
        2017.

53.   "Guyana vs. Panama". ESPN. June
        22, 2019. Retrieved November
        23, 2019.

54.   "United States vs. Trinidad and
        Tobago". ESPN. June 22, 2019.
        Retrieved November 23, 2019.

55.   Pokorny, Chris (June 5, 2016).
        DawgsByNature. Retrieved
        November 1, 2016.

56.   "U.S. Women's National Team vs.
        Federation. 2018. Retrieved May
        16, 2018.

57.   "Rapinoe, Heath Goals Lift WNT
        Retrieved August 20, 2018.

58.   Cooley, Patrick (January 19, 2017).
        Cleveland.com. Retrieved January
        19, 2017.

59.   Smith, Troy L. (January 18, 2017).
        Cleveland.com. Retrieved January
        19, 2017.

60.   Anderson, Chris (November 14,
        2017). "Taylor Swift concert tour
        Retrieved January 5, 2018.

61.   "Event Calendar". FirstEnergy
        Stadium.com. 2018. Retrieved
        March 17, 2018.

62.   Smith, Troy L. (July 15, 2022).
        Retrieved June 22, 2023.

63.   Benson, John (August 15, 2022).
        Retrieved June 22, 2023.

64.   Heisig, Eric (June 16, 2024). "The
        Scene. Retrieved June 25, 2024.

65.   "Tour". BillyJoel.com. Retrieved
        June 25, 2024.

66.   Baird, Nathan (August 22, 2022).
        cleveland.com. Retrieved October
        22, 2022.

67.   "Cleveland Monsters Outdoor
        ClevelandMonsters.com.
        Retrieved February 15, 2023.

68.   "John Carroll University's Men's
        2023. Retrieved December 8, 2023.

69.   O'Rourke, Jack (February 24,
        2023). "Blue Streak Club Hockey
        tournament run". The Carroll News.
        Retrieved December 8, 2023.

70.   Hamilton, Brad; Morrison, Laura
        (February 18, 2023). "'Special
        Fox8.com. Fox 8 News. Retrieved
        February 21, 2023.

71.   "Monsters prevail in Outdoor Classic".
        theahl.com. March 4, 2023.

72.   Lipcsak, Matthew (February 24,
        2023). "Youngstown Phantoms
        game in Cleveland". Mahoning
        Matters. Retrieved June 22, 2023.

73.   Lillstrung, Chris (February 27, 2023).
        Retrieved June 22, 2023.

74.   "Around the rink: Hockey and winter
        Stadium". NewsNet5.com. Retrieved
        June 22, 2023